
Last week, Adobe announced new agentic AI features, reigniting a conversation around the risks and benefits AI poses for creatives and creative teams.
As AI adoption expands, the primary concern for creators falls into two categories: creative integrity and job security.
We synthesized industry research and responses from Press Publish readers alongside conversations with creators Gannon Meyer, Shua Films, Lazy Millionaire, and Steven Bartlett to understand how creators are approaching the intersection of AI and creativity.
What we found was nearly every working creator is drawing the same boundaries when it comes to AI usage in their creative practice, and it’s not where the big tech companies think it is.
Creative integrity: Alongside their product roadmap, Adobe released a survey of 2,000 creators asking about their experience with AI.
78% of creators surveyed believe AI has accelerated their business growth and 59% of creators reported that AI agents save them time.
We asked Press Publish readers to weigh in, and only 17% agreed they were “all in” on agentic AI, while 56% don’t use it at all.
Across social media, the response to the Adobe MAX announcements was mixed with many creators sharing these updates were not what they were hoping for from the event.
"I feel there is a huge disconnect with the tech companies and understanding the true needs of artists and creatives,” Joshua “Shua Films” Buhangin told us. “The point of technological advancements in art is to help us have more time in the creation process. Not to just do it for us and put out more products.”
Job security: As AI tools expand, job security is more at-risk than ever. Creative companies like Disney, Pinterest and Canva have laid off thousands of employees. Now, creators are wondering if they’re being replaced next.
Today, between 21%-59% of feeds are getting taken over by AI-generated content. Creators whose income is tied to views fear they’re losing digital real estate as a result.
A survey published by Business Insider found creators earning six-figures were 64% more likely to feel pressure to use AI than creators earning less than six-figures.
After taking heat for using AI earlier this year, Hank Green explained his AI use came from creating “under a ton of pressure.”
Diary of a CEO founder, Steven Bartlett told us he believes the content that will win over AI is content that is hard, scarce and valuable.
“Hard means difficult to make. Scarce means that even if you were willing to do the hard thing, you couldn’t get the access. Value [means] humour, entertainment, information and so on,” Bartlett told us. “What people will always and increasingly value in a world of AI is [content that is] irreplaceably human.”
The case for a hybrid approach: During any technological renaissance, the prevailing wisdom often falls somewhere between total resistance and total adoption.
“I see AI as a way to speed up things, not start from scratch. It’s more like a 1 → 2 tool instead of a 0 → 1,” Gannon Meyer said. “There are parts of the creating process that I think are sacred, like writing. AI is more of ‘I don’t want to spend the next 30 minutes digging through folders of photos and B-roll I need for an edit—let me just have Claude do it for me,’ and not, ‘I need Claude to come up with my next video or to write my brand deal video script.’”
A similar sentiment was shared by other creators, too.
“I appreciate “AI” in the sense of removing things in the shot or making logos on a design auto align and reorganize in seconds,” Buhangin said. “Much like life, the point of art is the doing of it. Spending time to figure things out. And I feel that is the biggest part that is devastatingly misunderstood/misrepresented.”
While AI poses inherent risks to creators and creative work, it also is an opportunity for early-stage creators who are operating their creator business on a budget.
“If you're a single creator and you want to build a multi-million-dollar business, you can literally do that without having to hire anybody or work 15+ hours a day,” Amie Tollefsrud said. “AI is such an opportunity for creators to focus on the creative things that are more human that they actually enjoy doing. If creators can figure out their zone of genius and use AI for all of the other things, that’s the unlock.”
In conclusion: Creators and creative companies have a complicated relationship with AI.
As tools expand, established creators can outsource repetitive tasks and emerging creators have a lower barrier to entry to earn a living online.
But if creativity gets lost in the quest for efficiency, we risk creating a perpetual feed of homogeneous AI content.
Bartlett reminds us that history proves art and human connection has always found a way. His message for creators is this:
“I think a lot of creators still believe their job is to give people information. AI is making information almost free, and at the same time people seem to be getting lonelier,” Bartlett said. “When something becomes abundant it gets cheap, and when something becomes scarce it gets valuable. For creators, that means the thing worth tripling down on is whatever makes the person watching feel heard, seen, understood, less alone and connected. It’s the human stuff.



