- The Publish Press
- Posts
- Who's the Boss?
Who's the Boss?
How to stay creative in spite of the algorithm
Illustration by Garrett Golightly
How Creators Balance Creativity with the Algorithm's Demands
âAre you serving the algorithm or is the algorithm serving you?â
That question has been swirling around in our heads ever since Hasan Minhaj came on the Colin and Samir Show earlier this month.
Minhaj is no stranger to feeding the algorithmâhe came up on YouTube, creating shows like The Truth with Hasan Minhaj and Goat Face Comedy, which laid the groundwork for his performances on The Daily Show and Patriot Act.
âI just saw YouTube as a way to get your ideas out there and play your clips at a comedy show,â Minhaj said.
âI didnât know it was the beginning of something thatâd really help me out laterâmeaning come up with an idea, come up with a take, a perspective, shoot the thing, get the thing out, then rinse, wash, repeat, and own the stack.â
âOwning the stackâ means owning or controlling all points of creationâfrom writing and producing to editing and distributing.
âIt wasnât until the past couple of years that I realized that everyone that I really love pretty much owns the stack,â Minhaj said, referencing Jerrod Carmichael and Bo Burnham as creators who write, direct, star in, edit, and distribute their own work.
But owning the stack isnât plug and playâitâs not as simple as owning the means of production and selecting the platform for you. Because when you choose a platform, you choose to play by their rules.
In effect, really, truly âowning the stackâ has limitations. Sure, you can choose what to upload to YouTube and when to hit publish, but YouTube essentially owns the journey that content takes once itâs published.
Which brings us to feeding the algorithms. If you want people to see your content, you have to make content the algorithm will recommendâYouTube prefers a high click-through rate (CTR), Twitch prizes high retention, TikTok requires frequent posting. Creators know this all too well, which is why our stressors arenât the dentist or a first dateâtheyâre getting a 1/10 on YouTube or hiking your average view duration (AVD). Because getting your content in front of the right audience doesnât just feel goodâit keeps your business humming, your employeesâ salaries paid, and your brand partners happy.
Put it all together and many creators end up in âYouTube med school,â as Minhaj calls it.
âThe reason why we didnât go to med school or become engineers is so we wouldnât have to clock in and out for Deloitte. But now weâre doing that for YouTube. If you need to ask YouTube for a breakâyouâve lost.â
And thereâs the rub. How do creators stay true to their artworkââown the stackââand keep their creative business front and center without succumbing to the algorithm?
Every platformâs algorithm has different demands, so we talked to a group of short-form and long-form creators, producers, and operators to understand how they preserve their creativity without sacrificing their businessâs livelihood.
Ryan Ng, Film Creator
Ng creates short films on his YouTube channel and runs a film school via Patreon.
âI feel like there has been a rule book of how to become a successful creator over the last two years. I don't know if fighting is the right word, but I'm just not going to be following that rule book. I don't have an upload schedule. I stopped worrying about retention, and instead of asking myself âhow can I get the most clicks on this thumbnail,â I started asking myself âhow could I best reflect the emotions of the video in this thumbnail,ââ Ng said. âOnce I started thinking this way, I found myself taking inspiration from places I never thought of looking beforeâlike movie posters, album covers, and short films.â
Instead of focusing on metrics like CTR and AVD, Ng followed his own rules in his latest video Dear YouTube, I Hate You, where he describes his push and pull with the platformâs demands.
Another way Ng stays creative is by diversifying his output, whether that be posting on other sites or bringing in non-YouTube revenue from his film school. âDe-risking the process of being an artist is, in my opinion, the best way to stay creative and authentic on the platform,â Ng said.
Ng has developed a close group of creator friends including heyxnatalie, Beau Miles, Anthpo, and 8illy who support each other through the relentless process of creating videos. âWe started de-risking the artistic process by using our platforms to build businesses. None of us want to be financially reliant on our YouTube channels anymore, and because we're no longer worried about putting food on the table, this allows us to tell riskier stories.â
Sarah Renae Clark, Coloring Creator
Clark creates coloring tutorial and challenge videos and sells products like the color cube and color guide.
How to manage your job when itâs someone else's hobby: âEven if you LOVE your job, you need to give yourself space to switch off. And when your passion becomes your work, the lines get blurred. For me, that means whenever I draw, color, or do anything creative, Iâm wondering if I should turn on a camera just in case itâs useful for YouTube,â Clark said. âSo Iâve learned to find other hobbies, like puzzles, gardening, and video games, that are completely unrelated. And I refuse to monetize these, or Iâll have nothing to escape to in those moments when the job IS too much.â
Know your end-game. âI think itâs a great exercise for creators to stop and think about your âwhy.â Why are you doing this? What is the motivation beyond just numbers? What would you do if the algorithm didnât matter? And find a way to realign everything else with THIS as the focus, NOT the vanity numbers. For me, there were a lot of things I started saying ânoâ to and a lot of opportunities I decided not to chase when I really thought about the kind of creator I wanted to be, instead of always just trying to gain more followers.â
Literary Lola, BookTok Creator
Lola reads and reviews fiction and romcom novels on TikTok.
âI get burned out when Iâm in a reading slumpâŠwhenever Iâm not reading itâs hard for me to create content. But usually, I'll just take a couple of days off to regroup! I try not to be too hard on myself because at the end of the day, I read and make content for fun,â Lola said.
Set success on your own terms: âI determine my videosâ âsuccessâ on how much interaction they receive,â Lola said. âIf my followers comment/save my content, it makes me feel fulfilledâŠ.like Iâm helping someone. This also causes TikTok's algorithm to push my videos, so I'm able to be creative and serve my followers while also working with the algorithm.â
Harry Bagg, Producer and Thumbnail Designer
Bagg works full-time for Coffeezilla.
âI fundamentally believe that in order to create art, you must consume it. If youâre constantly consuming or constantly creating art, youâre going to be stuck in the same spotânever evolving, experimenting, or growing as a creative,â Bagg said.
And to consume art, you have to walk away from creating it for a while. âMusic artists make their albums then go on a hiatus for years or more just to experience life so they can write and record better songs,â Bagg said. âHowever, content creators donât have the luxury of being able to go away for years and experience life.â
So creators have to carve out that time for themselves. âI love my job and I wouldnât have any other in the world, but itâs very easy to let your life get caught up entirely into YouTube, get burnt out, or lose passion entirely if you put too much time into it. If I was constantly creating and not consuming, I wouldâve quit years ago,â Bagg said. âItâs crucial to spend time away from a computer and hang out with family and friends. Thatâs how you inspire and influence others.â
Our Take
Every creator has a different strategy to manage creativity and channel performance. When you exist on the spectrum between artist and distributor, expect yourself to fluctuate across it throughout your career. Even Rhett and Link said yes to every brand deal just to get food on the table at one pointâso donât beat yourself up about where you are today. Just take time to enjoy it.
And big picture: Being able to do the art you love and not care about its performance because you can sustain yourself on other income sources is a privilege. For most people, if their work isnât making money, they have to stop doing it, or at least pick up another job that does pay the bills. So for those who arenât full-time creatorsâyouâre in good company.
Sponsored by Acorns
Let's face it. Planning for retirement as a creator is scary.
Cashflow is unpredictable, algorithms are constantly changing, and consumer attention spans rival that of a goldfish.
Thatâs why itâs so important for creators to take control of their finances now, before itâs too late.
Enter Simplified Employee Pension Individual Retirement Accounts (try saying that five times fast).
SEP IRAs are designed specifically for the self-employed and offer a handful of perks like:
Flexible annual pre-tax contributions
Higher contribution limits than a traditional IRA
The ability to contribute to a SEP IRA and traditional IRA in the same year
Luckily, with the help of Acorns, opening up a SEP IRA is a breeze. Just set it, forget it, and watch your nest egg grow.
Want in? Find the right plan for you and get started with a $10 bonus from Acorns.
đ€ Creator Support
Publish Press readers share a problem they're facing and creators Colin & Samir respond with their advice.
Q: First of all, your newsletter on Bill C-11 was fantastic. But as a Canadian creator, now I have some concerns.
I'm a Canadian YouTuber in Canada, but I make Japanese content. Is this bill going to prioritize recommending my videos to Canadians rather than my core audience in Japan? I actually had this problem on TikTok at first, filling my inboxes with confused English comments.
Even though Iâve been blessed with a large audience, if my content stops being recommended to the right audience, I know thatâs going to lead to some problems. Iâd love to hear what you guys think.
Thank you so much for the work you do! You've played a big part in my YouTube journey.
(I go by ăă°ăă (ebason) on YouTube btw)
A: Evanâweâre so glad you liked our piece on Canada Bill C-11. We hope it was informative and empowering.
While the proposed bill doesnât have specific line items that directly address your concern of what will happen to Canadian creatorsâ content outside Canadian borders, we can piece together a few things from what we know about the intent of the bill.
Bill C-11 is meant to lift up Canadian-made programming within Canada and protect Canadian content from being ignored or undervalued by foreign companies. Its priority is improving the citizen experience, not imposing rules on the Canadian media companies that aim to reach Canada and beyond.
In terms of how your content is perceived, you should still be able to find your audience outside of Canada. The bill would mostly affect what Canadian citizens see. That said, if your content is served up to them just because itâs Canadian, not because itâs relevant to their specific interests, then youâre right that it could hurt your channelâs performance.
And depending on the size of your channel, C-11 could require you to prioritize government criteria for domestic distribution over global audiences, though thatâs still in question as the terms for creators that make user-generated-content (UGC) are still up for debate.
If you want to be part of amending C-11 so it removes the requirements for UGC creators like you, you can share your story here. In the meantime, give your audience a heads up. Tell them the situation and make sure your presence can be easily found elsewhere.
Facing a creator problem you want help with? Share it hereâ
đ„ Press Worthy
Markiplierâs OnlyFans threat is working.
Does TikTok know you better than you know yourself?
Pinterest added music to its TikTok-like feature Idea Pins.
Study prep materials are getting the TikTok treatment.
Charting Airrack's growth vs. MrBeastâs.
Gil Kruger launched Mentally Gil, a podcast discussing creatorsâ mental health.